Looking Forward to 2009

At the beginning of 2008, things looked kind of bleak hunt-wise. There hadn't been a BANG since April of the previous year and I had no idea when this hunger created in me would be sated again. (I went so far captain a team in Chinese New Year Treasure Hunt to feed said craving; it didn't help.) Things look a lot different for 2009: Two BANGs and a Game have already been announced.

That's to say nothing of the strongly-suggested-but-just-short-of-required (as Joe put it) responsibility laid upon two teams to host a BANG; the one, hopefully two, Microsoft Puzzle Hunts; theoretically another Shinteki Decathlon; the MIT Mystery Hunt; and any other unannounced hunts that are still in the planning stages. I'm hoping for about ten puzzle events next year, up from the six or seven we participated in this year.

Of course, I won't be able to make all of them; any that require airfare will probably be out of reach unless my donations to the California educations system pay off. However, the GNU will hopefully be represented at each event. For example, Jonathan is planning to head to Boston again this year to rejoin the Silly Hat Brigade for the Mystery Hunt and Given is thinking to join in the MSPH fun next time it occurs.

I could always try remote solving for events I can't attend; however, the one time I tried it in the past, it didn't work out very well. Maybe it was because I work better in groups or because the one puzzle I'd really got a handle on ended up being solved by someone on site while I was working on it.

Also, it doesn't help that Colin Mochrie & Brad Sherwood's Third Annual Farewell Tour is on the January 16...

Ghost Patrol Playtest - Final Part

(Part 1, Part 2, and Part 3)

Ghost 7: Here I Go Again

It was back to the hotel analog — aka Casa de Ashby — for our next ghost. One of the upstairs rooms had been transformed into a temporary hotel room; we were the first team there. Lining the wall was a series of gold records from different heavy metal bands, each with a number from one to ten spelled out underneath it. I heard one of my teammates note that the fact that they were spelled out was important as I excused myself to make use of the facilities. By the time I got back a few minutes later, they had solved the puzzle. To this day, I don't know how it works.

The early gray of dawn was showing as we got a box filled with bottles. Heading out to the van, we put the bottles on the drafting table and began to consider what to do with them. They were all corked or otherwise stoppered, which impressed me for some reason. Each bottle was filled with liquid and...

I blinked.

By the time I opened my eyelids, it was more than a half-hour later. The sun was up. The bottles were lined up in a row on the table and Brian from GC had joined us in the van. Jonathan was attempting to blow notes on the bottles. My first though after my inadvertent nap, similar to a famous bowl of petunias, was “Oh no, not again.” (Our disastrous showing at Iron Puzzler II had had a bottle puzzle that consisted of blowing on bottles to get notes out of them; it was a frustrating puzzles.) Brian was kind of walking us through the clue since it was a music puzzle and our abilities with music puzzles are our main weakness. Also, we'd completely missed the fact that we needed to use the UV light to reveal the right liquid level for each bottle. Because of said past experience and because I'd missed most of what was going on, I just watched and didn't even try to help.

Whatever lead we may have had in the unofficial competition was lost due to our performance on that clue. And we felt bad, too, since it was Brian's puzzle. I have to say our poor performance was more a reflection on our team than on the puzzle; for all I know it was beautifully constructed and amazingly elegant.

It was at this point that we lost our handler, probably to the lead team. It seemed kind of weird not having David or Jenn around, like there was too much empty space in the van as we headed to our next clue.

After the normal joys of finding parking, we followed the SHaRC under a freeway overpass, where strange metal statues were. We spotted a member of GC across the street, but she emphatically waved us away. Our clue was on this side. We found it in the form of a CD behind one of the statues.

This clue put a little bit of moral back into our team. Each track had two songs mixed into it and the titles of the song were anagrammed into another amusing title. Removing the letters in the actual song title from the fake song title left a letter, and thus the solve.

The capture was nearby. We had only done three clues for this ghost. Slightly depressing.

Ghost 8 – Idea Pooping

The sun had broke through the early morning clouds and it had turned into a gorgeous morning as we pulled up for our next ghost at Lake Merritt in Oakland. On our way there, Jonathan finally got in contact with BANG Erik who had been planning on joining us at around 11am the previous day. He hadn't been feeling well, but could now make it. Jonathan gave him directions to the park and we got out of the van.

There we say the impressive figure of Jesse in his lab coat and Meat Machine throwing bocce balls over an impromptu line. They were just finishing up as we arrived, so we took balls in hand and since there were four of us, each tossed a ball at the jack. Jesse consulted a sheet at exclaimed happily “Amazing!” (or was it “Awesome!”) Eric immediately got out his clipboard and started writing as we continued to make several additional bowls. It became clear pretty quickly that each bowl, depending on the order away from the jack would get another word of praise, such as “Va-va-voom!”, “Terrific!”, or “Great!” (to which Jonathan replied, “Great? That's all you can say about that bowl? How about 'glorious'?”), each of which started with a different letter of the alphabet.

Jonathan and Eric broke the code within a few bowls and Eric had the entire code written down in a few minutes. Okay, so what now? We rolled a few more just to make sure, exaggerating distances to the extreme in order to be exact, such as the time I threw the blue ball twenty-five feet from the jack in order to make absolutely sure it was the farthest away. Nifty encoding scheme verified, but what did we decode with it?

While discussing, someone looked over at the balls left by the other two teams and decided that it wasn't a case of GC being too tired to pick up the their balls after all; they were, in fact, the message we needed to decode. “GUM” was the answer and apparent flavor of ghost. Jonathan and I had a short discussion as to whether gum actually had flavor as we moved on.

(At GC HQ at the actual event, I found out that the answer had been changed to “GNU” in a small tribute to our team. Well, that and mainly that it worked with the constraints of the puzzles.)

Our next location was a bit away, but we decided to walk it. We wandered past the real bocce courts and beyond a professional croquet court — which had people in their cricket whites playing that morning. We came to another one of those “It's straight ahead, but we can't walk on water” situations and curved around the lake to find Meat Machine sitting at a small labyrinth. There we got handed a piece of paper with a bunch of ones and zeros on it.

We stared at it for a while. Different theories were postulated. None worked. At first, we thought they could be Morse, but then later groupings were eight digits long. We thought it could be binary, but then why would there be both “0” and “000”? After about ten minutes we began to run dry of ideas. Given or I postulated something, but Jonathan said it wouldn't work (something that had happened earlier when Jonathan argued against “dogfish”, not believing it was a real fish). Eric took exception to this and said, “Don't poop on an idea!” “Until it poops out on you,” I added.

I thought then that should be our new team motto.

We continued to stare at the sheet of paper covered in only two digits. We thought about taking a hint, but Jonathan convinced us that there was no real hurry. Meat Machine was still there. It was a beautiful morning. BANG Erik was to be joining us at that spot shortly (at least in theory). A nearby squirrel hadn't been able to give Given his nut yet, despite several attempts. And we only had a few puzzles to go before this amazing, once-in-a-lifetime experience was over. So we stayed.

Now at least twice in the past, I'd had an ideas for solutions that I dismissed as unlikely, which later turned out to be right. I now suddenly had a very crazy idea, and hoping to avoid the mistakes of the past, decided to work it out until it did poop out on me.

I grabbed the paper from Jonathan and twisted around. (I won't go into the details of my theory here since, although improbable, someone could read this far and I could develop a puzzle using the idea.) I worked it and worked it and it almost seemed to be bearing fruit. Based on what I was doing, Jonathan deduced my theory, got the paper back and tried it himself. “You know, it's actually kind of working!” But it didn't work completely and we gave up on it.

Jonathan called Greg for a hint. Greg didn't answer. As he was leaving a message, though, he cracked the puzzle.

[Spoiler: The still improbable reader may wish to avoid the next few paragraphs if they want to solve the puzzle themselves; instead, they should probably click the picture to the right.]

It was all the codes we'd previous thought, but only back to back. Decoding the first set yielded MOPERS. As Jonathan set about decoding the second set using binary instead of Braille this time, I mentioned that MOPERS is Morse with an extra P. That was our solve: Each of the classic encodings was being used to encode a word that was an anagram of the code plus one letter. Eric and Jonathan figured the last set would decode to ATMOSPHERE before even trying it, since they had seen the same word used in the same way in a Shinteki Decathlon.

Greg showed up and said, “I hear you guys need a hint?”

(I later told Ian, the puzzle's author, that it was the puzzle that went from most frustrating to most satisfying in the shortest period of time. I was actually kind of disappointed when they didn't use it for the Game.)

In talking with Greg a little about the puzzle, he mentioned that they planned to have teams retrieve the clue from the labyrinth using RC cars. It depended on the budget and feasibility, though. We thought it was a great idea and only wished we could have tried it.

The SHaRC indicated our next clue was back the way we came. In a real game, deciding to walk the long walk would have been disastrous.

Back at the van, we finally met up with BANG Erik who had parked next to us. We got him up to speed as much as possible as we walked past the once bocce ball-covered field and on towards our destination. We rounded a corner and saw that the lake again stretched in our way and would make for quite a detour.

“Let's take the van.”

With our newly-acquired fifth player in tow, we parked near an Obama rally that, surprising to me, seemed to have attracted very few San Francisco attendees. With propaganda-ish music blaring over the speakers, we crossed the street to where three colorful Z's were standing. Meat Machine was just finishing up and leaving as we got there and got our clue: A series of Taboo cards, each with a dark side. On the front were five words, as in real Taboo, that players weren't allowed to say. It was up to us to determine what the actual word was, though; that part was blank.

We quickly figured out that all the front words began with “TA”. On the back was a ghost saying a “BOO”-related word. Some of them had half-circles on the edges. All of the stickers had images on them. For some reason, I said, “Let's make a ring using the stickers to join them together.” I'm still not sure why. The idea apparently had its merits, though, and we put the stickers on cards that had word portions in common. The easiest sticker was probably “BOO”, which connected TABOO to BOO-BOO. With them all connected, a series of Roman numerals were created running inside and outside of the ring. A discussion broke out as to which order to read the numerals, since we had all assumed they stood for letters. At some point, though, Jonathan pointed out that the outside read “PRWNL”. “It has to be PERIWINKLE,” he declared.

I offered the SHaRC to our newly-arrived teammate so he could get a capture in. He declined.

Finale – A View to the Killed

Our end game was at a Mountain View Cemetery. Honestly, it's probably the largest cemetery I've ever been to. We reached a van point at pretty much the high point on the mountain. It was a gorgeous view and I tried to take a picture of it. Unfortunately, my digital camera was set to “movie”, which I didn't notice until later. All I got was one frame grab and a short movie of my shoes.

Everyone was there. GC Brian greeted us and explained what was going on. For the actual event, the OWL would explain this all, but right now it was him. The ghosts in containment had congealed into a single boss ghost and when this happened, teams would actually get to chat with the nerd ghost (nerd ghost? I hadn't seen enough puzzles for the previous two ghosts to get a handle on their personalities). He would explain that instead of trying to contain the ghosts, which only made them angry, it was better to figure out how to heal them emotionally... give them the proverbial closure. They would then leave this earthly plane forever.

At the circular base of the gravesite we stopped at were the final puzzles, several of which had slime associated with them. Had we actually done any slime analysis like I told the non-navigating, non-driving portion of our team to, we could identify which ghost belong to which puzzle by finding similar identifying slime at the site. Instead, though, those two teammates had been in the back of the bus solving puzzle steps we backsolved or guessed at. That or they were watching the animations that each capture code elicited from the OWL. Although I had heard them talking about them, I only had a chance to sneak a peak at the first one and pretty much forgot about them until this point.

We gathered up the puzzles and failed to identify the slime. To my horror, two of the samples I collected were labeled as the same ghost. Someone mentioned that there may have been two different slime samples out for the same ghost. It didn't matter in the end.

Eric grabbed one puzzle with pictures of famous people on it, some of them famously dead. He solved it quickly without even knowing which ghost it was for and Brian, again acting as our OWL, gave us the story as to how we had mollified that ghost. Jonathan figured a puzzle involving pets probably belonged to the Benign Booga and solved it pretty much on his own. We got another Brian ending. A bunch of phrases on a sheet of paper seemed like the same font that was used for the St. Mary's park flower puzzle, so we figured it was the Chinatown ghost. Another one consisted of letters on a grid. There were some interesting parts to it, but nothing that I could figure out. Given was working on a bunch of cards that had been divided in two.

Noticing our stalling on these final few puzzles, Brian mentioned that we may want to concentrate more on each ghost's motivation, revealed in the ending videos. Oh, and we may need scissors for the letters for the grid one.

We gathered up the clues and got back in the van to watch each of the videos again. They were impressive, though only in rough draft form. One or two only had a description of what the animation was to be like. But it was enough to solve the puzzles: We split the letter grid in two and actually saw the ending animation of the bi-polar ghost being split in two. I inferred that half of his personality had gone to hell, while the other went to purgatory. We then used the honor-binary system to solve the kung-fu fright's problem.

Up next was the circus lady. Her heart had been broken by another circus performer, so one of the Eric's figured we only needed to put the heart cards back together, mending her broken heart. He pointed out that the letters those cards represented anagrammed to TIME, the perfect solution. This led to a heated — but as always, good-natured — argument, with Jonathan arguing that we were discarding 75% of the data and there was no clear order to the hearts cards. Eric, Erik, Given and I took a side and even after Jonathan had entered TIME as the correct answer, we continued to argue whether it was a satisfying clue or not. Eventually, we agreed to disagree. It was a fun discussion though.

Which left us with the rockstar ghost. We looked at all the pictures covering the sheet of paper, but no ideas seemed to be coming. We watched his video and saw he wasted away and died while trying to write his ultimate song. But still, no ideas came. “Here,” I commented, “is how I would want this puzzle to solve: I'd want each of these pictures to actually be a musical note. The notes would then be from a song but would be missing the last few notes or something and those notes would then spell out the answer.” Jonathan sat forward. “How about if they contained musical notes instead? Like this bulldozer has 'do' in it. You know, do-re-mi?” We liked the idea and set about to figuring out the proper names of the pictures so to extract notes. When done, we figured we'd have to sing the notes to figure out which song it was and what to do next. That, unfortunately, was not going to happen. The other teams had left and it was getting late. We told Brian we knew what to do but the odds of us doing it within a reasonable timeframe were kind of sad. So he told us the end story of the final ghost being released, and the nerd ghost finally getting his dream of having an adventure fulfilled.

It was such a satisfying ending.

GC invited us to lunch at a eatery down at the bottom of the hill, five minutes away. We graciously accepted and after getting organized, headed out.

It took us a half-hour to get there.

New Nonoriddles - This is relevant to my interests

Yesterday, I ended up being too busy to post "Suit Type" for reasons that will become clear if you solve the puzzle itself.

All the times for "Attack Type" were under four minutes. Either that's pretty cool or I'm easily impressed. Two minutes thirty-seven seconds was david3x3x3's time, followed by joefendel at three minutes twenty-six seconds, and, ten seconds later, Prestemon at three minutes thirty-six seconds. Solution buttons are, of course, now available.

Ghost Patrol Playtest - Part 3

(Part 1, Part 2, and Part 4)

Ghost 5 – A Love/Hate Relationship

The hotel stand-in, Casa De Ashby, was our next destination. There, along with one or both of the other teams, we began to work on the cryptogram and other pieces of information at the dining room table, almost like a conference room puzzle event. GC gently suggested that we were welcome to move about the house, invading it to our hearts' content... appropriately marked doors being the exception.

Given discovered a car ad hanging on the refrigerator in the kitchen that indicated that the blacklight was needed. He got me with the blacklight and we found reason to believe that the light switches were also marked with invisible ink. We covered each light switch and found the numbers 1 to 9 written in almost Braille-like patterns on them. I copied down the patterns and we went back to the table to join Eric and Jonathan.

The cryptogram was tough. They'd made little headway with it. Finding no leverage point with the lightswitch data, I photographed and copied down the information on the post-its. The good doctor's sayings on the one side and evil person's on the other, with no overlap, made me want to push them through the wall and find out what the reverse of each saying was. No luck. Nothing was falling into place. Someone suggested we shine the black light on the skulls over the fireplace that had initially just looked like pre-Halloween decorations. There, Jonathan found some incomplete information, but it did not help us.

We thought we were working on four different puzzles. Someone from GC (I think) mentioned that most of the data was all connected, so perhaps there were only one or two. We still had made no headway when GC told us and the other teams that we needed to head out because of the timing of the other locations.

(I got the impression while looking through documents at GC HQ during the actual event that the colored cryptogram had been the key to the whole thing and that some of the data we'd gotten out of it was correct, but apparently we hadn't made the right leap to solve the whole thing. And by “we”, I mean Jonathan and Eric, who were the only ones to try it.)

GC gave us directions to the next location; the SHaRC didn't have the right data for it. We started to walk off, when Given and Jonathan said they needed to head back to the van and that they'd catch up to Eric and I. Eric lead the way and two turns later, I was unsure how our two lagers were to catch up with us.

Immediately upon arrival, my brain shut down. Sure, it left enough systems running for breathing and circulatory measures but none of the new data that was being presented to us was being recorded in my soft drive. We were in an empty house with painting of people committing suicide on the wall, each casting different colored shadows. A wooden model of the human form was on a nearby table with a piece of paper with some writing on it. It may have even been in English. Meat Machine was already there when we arrived; I don't know about There Be Dragons, maybe they were too. My addled brain can't quite remember.

There was too much data for either of us, so Eric and I headed into the back room where we encountered a easel, a painting, a wooden pallet with three paints on it, and a paint-by-numbers diagram hanging on the wall. A member of one of the other teams was in there looking it over. He asked me to turn off the light (which I did) and he shone the blacklight on the painting and pallet, revealing hidden colors. Neat! I though. Where's the bathroom?

It seemed like an hour later when Jonathan and Given arrived. It was probably only ten minutes. I spent the time seeing, but not comprehending. I don't know what Eric did. I took Jonathan on a tour of what we had scene, when the last remaining spark plug fired in my brain and I realized that it wasn't different people committing suicide, but was the same person failing at it several times and they needed to be in order. Jonathan and I worked that out and then I pretty much returned to my oblivious state.

I sat down in the corner of the room and just stared. My teammates joined me and stared too. We didn't talk. Jonathan swears I was asleep with my eyes open. None of us were doing anything. We watch the other teams wander around, but they didn't seem to be making more progress than we were, but at least they were trying.

Eventually, our team got enough rest to kick start the brains. I watched as they consulted the piece of paper which showed that day of the actual Game, there would be lights above the wooden model, arranged on a grid. (I assumed at the time that it would be in scale with the model, but found out much to my jealously, that full-blown colored spotlights were used.) They figured out how to get data from the grid based on the color of the shadows, only it wasn't making sense. Jonathan was about to ask GC for a hint, but found GC talking to There Be Dragons about how some of the blue shadows could be considered different colors. That was pretty much the clarification we needed and came to a solution not to long after that. I'm still not sure how the puzzle works; my brain complains loudly every time I try and revisit it.

Heading into the backroom again, someone finally spotted that we were working with binary. Meat Machine's working group had left, so we felt free to work on the puzzle. I actually was able to contribute in deciding which colors were which.

At some point, I'm not even sure how or where or when, we got a sheet of paper showcasing some modern art soon to be displayed. It consisted of a bunch of lines and a rather large frame. Extending the lines gave us “MIN WAX”, which took us a second to decode to “WANE”, which the OWL didn't accept, so we entered “WAYNE” as a likely name homonym. It worked.

We left the artist's house about the same time as There Be Dragons (I keep wanting to write that as There Might Be Dragons for some strange, musical reason). We could have gone on to the capture point, but one of our members was using the facilities, so it may have looked like to them that we were set to follow them. After seeming to eavesdrop on their clarification conversation with GC, it may have looked like we were trying to ride their coattails. Our member got back just as TBD set out, further giving that impression. They made some good-natured jokes — at least I hope they were good natured — about us; we good-naturedly protested our innocence.

Ghost 6 – A Chili Morning

We were told that our next location was at a house, but we weren't supposed to go in, despite what the SHaRC said. We grabbed the van and drove to the house. There we found three sticks as stand-in gravestones with team names written on them, with a box at the base. It was probably Jenn who informed us that for the actual event, the boxes would be buried and teams would have to dig up their own grave. Neat idea, plus we were the first team to arrive.

We had parked the van across the street next to a play park, so that seemed like a natural place to solve. It had good lighting and uncramped solving possiblities that the van just didn't provide. I'm still not quite sure how it happened, though, but despite being the first team to pick up our box, the other two teams were already solving in the park when we arrived.

Our new ghost was a fortune teller and in the box were chicken bones with red stamps of various symbols. Based on another activity I had done, I figured the symbols needed to be placed right up against each other in the same orientation. I set about assembling the bones like that, but it became pretty clear that that was not to be: It was too rickety and not all the symbols could work. We were fairly certain, though, that we had the right idea, and someone had the bright idea of breaking it down by symbol type, since that was the way the different symbols were shown in our guide. It worked and we left the park with a bit of a lead.

Another house was our destination now, only this one we could go into. We were greeted by someone way too enthusiastic and alive at 3 or 4am. He brought us into his house and offered vegetarian chili with toppings. We didn't take him up on it immediately but did compliment him on his large collection of board games. “That,” he said, “is only about a quarter of what I own.”

Our next clue seemed pretty intriguing. It was a Ouija board, only much thicker than, say, the one in our GP application video. We played around with it and found it buzzed sometimes when passed over certain letters. I had formulated the theory that we'd have to pass the pointer over each number in the center and then pass it over all the letters to find out which letter went in that position. Greg stopped by and mentioned that he wasn't sure it was working right yet. He handed us our next puzzle. I kept playing around with it anyway, trying to get to buzz consistently when passing over any letter. But it just wasn't happening, so we got some oh-so-delicious-and-much-needed-everyone-had-two-bowls-and-almost-wanted-three chili and turned to the star puzzle.

(Jenn continued playing with it even after I gave up on it, though, and eventually got it to work... kind of. To celebrate, she took a nap in the living room.)

The star puzzle consisted of several stars that were basically paths with a symbols at each corner. A list of overlapping symbols was also given to us; two overlapping symbols would form a letter. Traversing each star would then yeild a set of overlapping symbols that we could decode. It seemed fairly difficult, but we gave it a try as to what symbols stood for what. Other teams trickled in and finally Eric and I figured out that the five single-symbols corresponded to vowels, and the rest fell quickly after that.

Back in the van, we got a group of six test-tubes, each filled with a colored liquid. Across the top of each tube was a letter and together they spelled SPRITE. So that's why we'd been carrying around a mini-Sprite bottle that came in our GP satchel. Only thing is, when opening a mini-bottle of Sprite that you've been carrying around all day long, there's going to be a pressure release.

After a hasty cleanup, we figured we needed to fill each test tube to the marked level with the Sprite. Jonathan did and the liquid in each changed color. The second one got a little overfilled though, so we had to kind of guess at it what it would have been. So now what? Our consensus was that we change each letter by how far each color had changed up or down the color spectrum. The “S” went down four, the “P” stayed the same, the “R” down three, the “I” up six, the “T” down four, and the “E” down six.

Jenn gave a laugh and said, “Now it says 'OPOOPY'.”

Which it did. We may have even typed it in, but to no avail. It seemed like the perfect solution, so we kept at, rechecking our data, making minor, questionable adjustments (“Maybe that green is more yellow?”), and always coming up with nothing. Another classic case of being stuck in the rut of an idea. Eventually we asked for a hint and soon figured out that the colors were associate with the letter beforehand. So, for example, since the “E” started off blue (or whatever it was), everytime we saw a blue color after the transformation, it was an “E”. And thus, OPOOPY became PEPPER.

(We suggested that maybe the letters on top could match the color of the original liquid in the test tubes since by the time we came to the proper conclusion we only had Jonathan's amazing memory and Eric's amazing notes to rely on.)

I don't remember the capture of this ghost. That may be because I was only functioning on a cylinder or two, or because, as Jenn noted, the captures were somewhat anti-climatic. She was thinking that maybe the capture site should be where the slime was located, or perhaps have some sort of light show to indicate that the capture was complete.

Final part is next...

Muppet Movie Game Thoughts

I love the idea that Orange Snood is going to be blogging about their creative and thought processes during the creation of their Game for next fall. It's especially good for those of us who might be considering running a Game in the future and advice from an experienced team is always helpful. Although I have opinions of questionable validity (I've technically only played in one full-lenth Game) one way or the other about various aspects of Game play, my main thought is that every event should have T-shirts. Yes, T-shirts. There need to be more T-shirts. Definitely.

Well, that and I wonder if the number of applications received is a function of how far in advanced a Game is announced...

The Ghost Patrol Playtest - Part 2

(Part 1, Part 3, Part 4)

Ghost Three – The Pirate of Presidio

Getting to our next site of our new ghost proved to be a challenge in and of itself. While we knew that our location was across the street from a sports shop, the sports shop turned out to be on a street that occurs more than once in San Francisco, thus confusing our GPS system, and thereby us. Eventually, we found the right street with some help from David, and parts of it looked very familiar: Jonathan and I spotted at least two clue locations from BANG 18.

We parked it front of the sports shop and headed across Crissy Field to find a treasure chest and several markers in the sand. GC informed us that we needed to blindfold two members and have the other two direct them to the various markers to dig up whatever treasure therein lay. Given and Jonathan volunteered to be blindfolded. Eric controlled Jonathan and I controlled Given. Given was interesting, since apparently a “giant step” is one foot in front of the other, where a tiny step is inching along. Jonathan's giant step was a full stride and could explain to some degree why they ended up winning the unofficial in-team competition.

Each site contained a buried box with a washer and a word written on it. We figured pretty quickly, as There Be Dragons started to arrive, that each of the objects in the large treasure box to the side contained in the words on each washer, with an extra letter. Before we headed off, though, GC mentioned to us that the next clue location might need a hint to find due to the limitations of GPS. “Under bridge” were the two words she gave us, so I immediately thought our next stop was the Pet Cemetery we had visited for the Perplexcity Live event two years ago.

The SHaRC took us along the shore towards the Golden Gate Bridge. We came to a point, though, where a military-looking building had a crossarm down across the road and nobody manning the station. So we turned back and began an adventure in finding roads that might go under the bridge. We nearly ended up going over the GGB, but luckily we were able to spot our problem before the Vista exit. Having given up on the Pet Cemetery idea, we were thinking that our location was possibly near the road that ran under the bridge, connecting the two Vista stops. No luck, but walking around the Vista, we kept following the SHaRC until we came to the edge of a cliff. It said we still had a few hundred feet to go, though. Looking down, we spotted Fort Point, which, had that crossarm been up, we would have reached twenty-seven minutes earlier.

Finally arriving at Fort Point, we got a CD, but were told because we arrived so late that we only had about fifteen minutes to work on the clue. We were somewhat disheartened by that and by the fact that it was a musical clue, our Achilles heel. Jonathan spurred us on with a rousing “We can do this!” so we set to listening. A joyful Irish pub song started coming out of the speakers. Three voices sang, each in a different range. Figuring we needed to figure out which was was singing which part of the song, we tried to figure out which was which. And tried. And tried. And pretty much failed. At some point, Jonathan started wondering if there might be stereo channel encoding, a la Midnight Madness, but Windows Vista's ability to adjust channel levels was strangely hidden (at least compared to XP's) and it took some time to find the right controls. Sure enough, there was, lending another complexity to gathering the data. The conclusion, thus, was that it was a braille encoding (“One of the more brilliant braille encodings I've seen,” Jonathan opined at a later point). With our fifteen minutes all but gone and still finding it very difficult to discern between the two higher pitched voices, we allowed ourselves to be skipped and sent to the next location.

Our next location was the Pet Cemetery.

One team was finishing up and the other was about half-way through at the site when we pulled up, showing again that our puzzle-solving times are severely hampered by our (in)ability to drive between locations. The sun was setting but there was still enough light to not require flashlights. We were handed a bunch of faux Polaroids with names blurred by ghostly vapors and saw a bunch of numbered flags inside the graveyard. I was looking forward to seeing Malarky again, but alas, I didn't see his headstone (headboard?) anywhere.

As the other team left, we began gathering the pet name, flag number, and flag color associated with each photo. A few were a little challenging to find, but we had no specific search pattern apart from “Here, you take these photos and see if you find them.” We went back into the van after that and Jonathan typed the data into a spreadsheet. I sat with him on the back bench while Given went over the data that Eric had written down. Were there instructions to group the names or did it come to us? Regardless, we saw that “King” and “Queen” were likely groups, and thought that “Duke” and “Baron” would also fit nicely in that category. Figuring four to a category, we ran into problems and thus many discussions of how to fit name “X” into category “Y” when it clearly didn't fit, despite being the only one left over. Eventually, because of the colors and being the only way to sort some of them, we settled on pairs and soon solved it.

While we had been solving at the Pet Cemetery, darkness had fallen. We followed the SHaRC to the beach and down a stretch of path near some old structures that may have been buildings at some point. At the far end, we met GC who told us the clue we were actually headed for was unavailable (was it the sand dollar clue?) and directed us to the structures. Along a circular platform were a series of shells each with a strip of paper on it. Jenn told us they planned to have actual sounds coming from the shells instead of those described on the paper strips. So we grabbed them all along with a treasure map and headed back to the van, GC Jenn (and companion) accompanying us.

The thing is, GC David had abandoned us. Earlier he had let us know that he had a date with his girlfriend that night. After some good-natured ribbing — after all, he could have a date any night, but how many chances would he get to watch the Smoking GNU solve puzzles? — we found out that his replacement was to be Jenn. Whereas David was tight-lipped while watching us (pretty much how I figure I would be if and when I would be in his position), not wanting to give anything away, Jenn was much more conversational. She even helped work some puzzles she hadn't seen before, including this one.

Back in the van, we rolled out the map on the drafting table. The 36-point compass with E,S,N, and W in strange positions was there. Recognizing it from the pre-clues, we decided that we had to match the sounds on the paper to locations on the map, find their angle using the protractor (I forget the ingenious name it was given) provided in our kit. Only thing is, we needed a straight edge. “Somebody get me a ruler,” said Jonathan. I reached a hand into my backpack, knowing I had two rulers in there, and groped around until I found one. Pulling it out and slapping it on the table, I was surprised: It wasn't the normal ruler, but the "Rolling Ruler". A look of surprise crossed the team's faces as well, but we settled down to using it.

We all tried sounding things out, much to Jenn's amusement (she eventually said she was going to recommend against the recorded sounds because of how much fun we were having). Emphatic discussions came about as to what the difference between rain and a waterfall was, aurally, and others. You'd think some would have been simple, but pretty much every sound had pros and cons argued for it. We finally settled on a few, with Jenn's input, and started to draw a line between them to prepare for angle measuring (which didn't look like a pretty job since we only had the paper's bottom edge as a baseline), when Eric stopped us. “Look,” he said, “all you need to do is roll the ruler across the paper to the compass. It'll keep the same angle and save a lot of trouble.” We tested his theory and it worked. It made me feel proud, like it was an amazing contribution I'd made, when really all it was was pure chance that I hadn't grabbed the other ruler from my backpack.

Based on the way the pre-clue had worked — i.e.pairs of locations — Jonathan figured the angle between locations one and two would form a word, then three and four, etc. I all-to-briefly argued that it should be the journey, one to two, two to three, etc., but was overruled. We tried our the ruler and our theory and got letters that seemed to work, so we kept going, hoping the ones we weren't sure about wouldn't prevent us from filling in the gaps.

“ATTENTION THE PARK IS NOW CLOSED! PLEASE EXIT IMMEDIATELY!”

A police cruiser had entered the parking lot and was encouraging people to leave, and somehow the tone of voice seemed to imply anyone at the park that late at night was a drug dealer, a pervert, or both. As we got ready to leave

“GET OUT OF THE PARK NOW! IT IS CLOSED!”

...Jenn mentioned that they had permission to use the park late at night on the evening of the actual Game, but not tonight. We finally got in position to drive out and

“LEAVE NOW!”

... found a point just outside the parking lot to solve. Someone mentioned that the police usually weren't this forceful, but that there was a race the next day and they probably wanted to make sure everything was perfect for it.

By this point we had something like “B O D O _ G _”. Hmmm, I remember thinking, it's too bad we don't have some extra letters in there, we could make “BLOOD ORANGE”, but the idea seemed so ridiculous that I kept it to myself (a folly I need to stop). “BODO?G?” didn't seem to be yielding anything close to an answer, so we tried reworking some of the sound locations, but were pretty satisfied with what we had. It was then that Jenn recommended that we try the “journey” method and see if it gave us anything different. It did: We got all of “BLOOD” and didn't need to do the rest; my seemingly wild hunch had proved true, making me feel pretty dumb.

Ghost Four – Clowning Around at the Wharf

Due to constraints, that was the last clue we got for that puzzle and so we never got to capture the ghost. Somehow I missed that bit of information in transit. That explains why, when we arrived at the Museum Mechnique, I thought we were still solving for the pirate instead of immediately SEQing our new ghost. Jenn handed us our puzzle and explained that day of, the small card we got would actually come from the fortune machine. One of our team decided to get a “real” fortune to make the experience more complete. The puzzle seemed to take no time to complete and it wasn't long before Jenn handed us our next puzzle and recommended that we go eat while solving.

That sounded like a great idea and Jonathan was aching for clam chowder in a bread bowl. We found the nearest restaurant that served them, only to find they were out of bread bowls.

Deciding not move, we got out the papers and found that we had to cut out different parts of a Venn diagram, only we had left our scissors back in the van. Oh well, we could do this by hand. It's always interesting the discussions teammates get into during these types of puzzles. For example, we decided that one diagram represented a bald, blue person with a single name. Bald and blue meant it had to be Blue Man Group, but we could not find a way to make them a single name (it turned out that the third category was “musicians”). Once we got it all done, we had six new categories we figured we would make into another Venn diagram. Using tiger, ringleader, Blue Man Group, balloon, rainbow, and Bill Murry, we had difficulty making a good diagram.

Eventually, we decided that since a proper Venn diagram has six colors, that each of the objects had to be a color: Blue Man Group, obvious. Tiger, obvious. Ringleader usually wears red pants. We changed the rainbow (an arc in the sky) to sun (a group of arcs in the sky) to get yellow, and decided that the balloon had to be purple, and, stretching even further, that Bill Murry was green (bill=American paper currency=green). Using those as guidelines, we put the diagram together and came up with the idea that the answer had to begin with a “B” (Bill, Blue Man Group, and balloon), be circus related (tiger, balloon, ringmaster), and be a sports team (Suns, Tigers, and the Bills). We started naming sports teams that began with “B”, but none of them were really circus-related, until it hit me: Bears! We were so sure it was right, despite the leaps in logic we made, that disappointed when it didn't work.

We went back and reworked things with our original data. Somehow, Jonathan pulled CLOWN out of it, which apparently the OWL accepted and translated as “Clown Blue”. I never saw that, though, hence my confusion at Rich Bragg's confusion at getting the same answer when I was staffing the site a few weeks later.

The next site the SHaRC took us to was down the wharf to a Ben & Jerry's. There we met a nonoriddle fan (hi catherwood!), although unbeknown to us at the time, who gave us a box of animal crackers. This was a fun puzzle and one that seemed all together too short. We quickly realized that the broken animal cookies each corresponded to a part of their name and were off not to long after that.

A sheaf of paper puzzles was our reward when we arrived at... the heart of Pier 39? I can't say I was exactly paying attention. All I can remember was that it was well lit, we were surrounded by shops, and the place was virtually deserted. Jenn mentioned that we should be careful with the laptop, as some punk had tried to steal Greg's at that exact spot. Luckily, the would-be-thief didn't quite have a good enough hold on it to complete his crime.

We divided up each of the mini-puzzles and I got the one with a circus tent on it and a strangely-metered poem. One of the lines sparked off the idea on how to solve it fairly quickly. Now, I'm more than familiar with the Mad Magazine's Fold-in, but that's not what inspired the idea of folding the A to the B several times over; I'd actually been revisiting The Secrets of the Alchemist Dar the week before the playtest and was expanding on my theory that some of pages needed to be folded. Regardless, I folded into a fan with a picture of a fan and the word “booster” from the poem. Booster confused me until someone, Given or Jenn, pointed out that “booster” was also a type of fan, albeit usually one in a sports connotation.

(David came by to visit us later and asked after the mini. It had been his and was surprised that in one of the previous playtests, no one could solve it. Apparently, they'd never read the proper literature.)

It became apparent shortly afterwards that we were working on a puzzley version of the blind men and elephant fable. “You know,” Jonathan said, “we could look it up on the Internet and fill in the crossword fairly quickly, but I think it'd be more fun to solve it.” So my fan translated into an “ear” in the crossword. I started looking at the other minis to try and help solve. Given was working on a color-by-numbers puzzle that appeared to have a flower, the letter “E”, and a yellow and black zipper, all on some bricked object. It's funny, I thought, that the “E” is on a wall, since that would be “Wall-E”, the Pixar film. To me, it was just a random thought until, with Jenn's nudging that the zipper was a street, we figured out that they were all “wall” objects.

So once again, an unspoken though of mine actually turned out to be the answer. I promised myself I would speak out more often, and I really took that idea to new levels the next day.

With that one solved, we walked further along the pier and spotted a huge cruise ship. As we got closer, Jenn mentioned that next to it was the world's largest sailboat. It was so dark out, we could barely see it. I took a picture of it, but turned out horrible (the version at right is one that someone else took). Apparently, it was up for sale.

On the wooden dock in front of the boat were several wooden cutouts of circus folk with openings for faces. Mustaches had been attached to each one, all in the shape of a letter. GC suggested we should take some tourist pictures. So we did. Some parts of the pictures lit up with the flash and they were all groups of unique numbers. We somewhat assumed that there was one grouping per cutout, but if our theory that the number, say five, indicated that the mustache letter, say “M”, was in that position, then we were missing some. Other teams arrived, so we consulted my camera to see if there was more than one per cutout. It looked like it, so I sprinted back to one of them to verify that the painting was reflective and not just a trick of the light. Verified, we got our answer and our capture valiance.

As we left, we spotted some people taking real tourist pictures with the cutouts.

We walked further down the wharf, captured our ghost, and headed back to the van. Our next assignment, we found out, was back across the bay, in the hotel.

Part three is here...

An Experiment in Romantic Nonoriddles

In an experiment I've been meaning to try for a few months, today's 6x6 "Love Style" nonoriddle comes in two forms: Easy and hard. The only difference between the two is that the hard version has a couple of the numbers replaced with "?". Each question mark represents a single number of an unknown value and adds another layer of deduction.

Although the code changes were minor and I've gone over the hard version many times to make sure it is solvable with logic alone, please let me know if any problems are encountered. Also, if submitting a fastest time, please note if you solved the hard version; otherwise, I'll assume you did the easy (or should it be called "normal"? hmmm...)

Last week's "Eighties Rapper" garnered four solve times: Fifty seconds from joefendel, fifty-one seconds from david3x3x3, fifty-nine seconds from my sometimes teammate Prestemon (Hi Eric!), and a minute one from Jetzm.